Thread

1. ryandrake · 1791149394 · focus · HN ↗

   Reminds me of all the de-crufting you've always needed to do when you install Windows. Looks like we've gotten to the point on macOS too, where you need to run third party scripts on a new OS installation to gain back control of your system resources and remove unwanted crapware.

   1. 2muchcoffeeman · 1791150186 · focus · HN ↗

      On windows you got garbage like trial versions of Blah software.

      This is a fully functioning feature that people don’t like for what ever reason.

      1. 2III7 · 1791150657 · focus · HN ↗

         Fully functional feature consuming multiple gigabytes of storage and has questionable functional value. Maybe people don't want bloated AI crap on their desktops?

         1. Stitch4223 · 1791152353 · focus · HN ↗

            “Some people” arguments always hold true.

            Old classmates back in the day used to hate the 128 × 128 px icons macOS shipped. A waste of space for eye candy.

            12 GB is at most 4.68% of your Mac. Improving on Apple Intelligence is something of value, as is consumerizing local-first AI.

            We’re not talking adware here.

            1. verandaguy · 1791153080 · focus · HN ↗

                   > Improving on Apple Intelligence is something of value
               

               Not if you didn't use apple intelligence in the first place (and/or aren't interested in using it going forward).

                   > as is consumerizing local-first AI
               

               If and only if there is actual demand for it. If most users do not want this, it's a bad feature.
            2. samudrijan · 1791155531 · focus · HN ↗

               That’s a whole 4% of my disc. Get that out of there.
            3. appletrotter · 1791156054 · focus · HN ↗

               Apple's AI and harnesses are trash and a complete waste of space

               Also suggesting that sacrificing 1/20 of your disk space is NBD is crazy. I have to prune space on my drive all the time because macs ship with the least amount of disk space that apple imagines they can get away with as possible.

            4. groundzeros2015 · 1791156148 · focus · HN ↗

               Are you arguing that the icons did not occupy a scarce resource that could have been used for other things? Or that the value is so obvious it we worth it?
            5. athoneycutt · 1791157054 · focus · HN ↗

               Useful or not there should be an option to turn it off and get space back (plus avoid LLM) if you want.
            6. bloqs · 1791157306 · focus · HN ↗

               4% of my disk on a computer with soldered storage hardware?

               Is the marketing really getting this good?

               1. EA-3167 · 1791157871 · focus · HN ↗

                  This is going to shock you I suspect, it seems to be something many here fail to consider in any number of circumstances: You don't represent a majority of anything. A majority of people buying Macs, a majority of people they market to, a majority of who they design for, a majority of who they product test against. In fact I'd venture to guess that you like many here represent a vocal portion of a tiny minority that are almost impossible to please without the sort of full customization of hardware and software you want. It's much easier to neglect that small market in favor of the one that prints them money, and I'm always baffled that so many don't understand that.

                  People here misunderstand just how different they are to the norm. "I want x, y, z to be free so I can modify it!" Most people buying Apple products don't, hell most people buying any phone doesn't want that, they want a smartphone that works out of the box and never fails to be a smartphone. The walled garden is largely a feature and not a bug, it's just not a feature you want, just like the aesthetics, social factors, ease of use, etc don't matter to you as much as function.

                  Most people aren't like that.

                  1. klrefg · 1791180767 · focus · HN ↗

                     > a majority of people they market to, a majority of who they design for, a majority of who they product test against

                     As if Apple is always right and knows what their users want. Sure they are more often than other companies but stuff like the touchbar and Siri itself for that matter prove that they do in fact make mistakes.

            7. isityettime · 1791159476 · focus · HN ↗

               5% is huge. And the way app bundles work on macOS, tons and tons of disk space gets burned up for each application relative to on an OS like Linux distros, so each GB doesn't go as far in the first place.

               It's also not the full extent of disk usage by built-in apps which aren't removable by normal means on macOS. An empty macOS installation is like 35 GB. NixOS is not known for being particularly space efficient, but 30-40 GB is how much space I use on it for the OS and all applications, including a ton of developer tools, on my graphical systems. For the base OS with a full fat desktop environment, most Linux distros have you looking at less than 10 GB. So this comes as a massive increase on an OS that already burns a ton of disk space before you even get to touch it.

            8. quaddoggy · 1791161993 · focus · HN ↗

               Yes, but it’s death by a thousand cuts. I encourage you to see how much BS space is taken up by iMovie or Live Photos or whatever on your iPhone. If every team at Apple wants their percentage you end up with less.

               1. mahboi · 1791166938 · focus · HN ↗

                  iMovie isn't installed by default, and live photos are an option at least. Apple Intelligence requires ripping out with sketchy scripts.
            9. jtbayly · 1791162668 · focus · HN ↗

               Wrong. 12GB is potentially 9.4% of your disk. At the very least, the original M1 MacBook Air (perhaps others) could be purchased with 128GB of storage.

               1. 52sk · 1791173252 · focus · HN ↗

                  The M1 MacBook Air did not have a 128 GB storage option.

                  1. alwillis · 1791183237 · focus · HN ↗

                     > The M1 MacBook Air did not have a 128 GB storage option.

                     There was an 128 GB model [1] that was only sold to schools.

                     [1]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;everymac.com&#x2F;systems&#x2F;apple&#x2F;macbook-air&#x2F;specs&#x2F;macbook-air-m1-8-core-7-core-gpu-13-retina-display-2020-specs.html" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;everymac.com&#x2F;systems&#x2F;apple&#x2F;macbook-air&#x2F;specs&#x2F;macbook...

            10. penskymaterial · 1791165370 · focus · HN ↗

                Bruh the entire Mac OS used to fit in 20 GB and nothing they have added since has meaningfully improved my life, though some has made it more difficult.

                That extra space is for my media.

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.