This isn't much of a test, but I bought $10 in credits on their playground and generated a test image. Not bad, but it didn't get the accordion keyboard right. Haven't tried editing yet.
It works. You have to prompt for it. It helps to have an LLM help build your prompt with you, while you learn what the models need to read to do what you need. Especially a vision one, you can supply images and ask it to give you details on what you want help with.
The Champ de Mars park has that general vibe and is presumably the primary training reference source here, but it definitely doesn’t look exactly as depicted here.
Let's see. Yeah, the lighting is good
- Location isn't quite right. The side gardens on the Champs de Mars are much wider than this. They're not in this style either :)
- Melty coins, and keyboard.
What else?
- Bunch of visible shape inconsistencies: building window sizes and alignment, fence railing, rivets on the bench, coins, accordion features, perspective violations etc...
- Metal clips on the bottom and top edges of the carrying case are on different sides. Said clips look inconsistent.
- One of the case straps originates inside (from under the velvet, even), the further one originates outside. The carrying handle is oddly mis-centered (as with most things).
- I'm not sure that accordion, compressed, fits in that case. She can just about stand in it (diagonally, on one foot).
- It has weird folds that disappear partway through and turn into adjacent folds going the other way. Between this, the keyboards and the dots, I'm sure there are other things wrong with accordion anatomy.
- Awkward left hand: not sure what's going on with the metacarpal joints, and index finger appears to begin forking into two tips pressing into two (misshapen) buttons. Her right hand is getting there too.
- Weird hair midline. I haven't seen a "sub-midline" like this in the wild :)
- The burgundy coat clips through the bench under her right leg. It's like the front slat goes through a hole in the side of the coat.
- We don't usually have that side curling bar on each side of the sitting area. It looks like it's clipping through the flats next to the leather handbag
- Ill-placed buckle on that bag.
- The green metal fence on the right begins behind her for one vertical bar, next one disappears into the plants, no further vertical bars, no top horizontal railing. Actually, it appears to only have fencing on one side, that's not something I'd see often. On the side where it does have a top, its top rail has very irregular width.
- Sand looks like... breadcrumbs? Very repetitive coarse shapes, like it was poorly done with a clone stamp.
- Something weird about the leaves.
- The foremost lamp isn't sure whether it has flat sides or not.
- The other lamp emerges out of nowhere from behind one of the blob-people in the alley.
- A bunch of unfortunate tangents and occlusions which make you wonder whether the diffusion hallucinated detail out of bigger shapes, or if it's been trained on photos where the tangents were done on purpose.
ie. center bottom bar of the bench being exactly aligned with the gray edge tiles, side curly railing-not-present-on-our-real-benches fully formed on her right, almost completely foreshortened out of existence where the bench's perspective forbids it...
Most people are fooled by much cruder fakes though. This is a lot better but keeps plenty of tells for observant people (and most people aren't)
When I was a kid, there was a game in the funny pages that asked you to find six things wrong in a picture. Someone should run a contest like that for AI-generated images.
It might be an interesting benchmark for vision models, too.
skybrian · · focus · HN ↗
<a href="https://pages.skybrian.com/flux3-image-test/" rel="nofollow">https://pages.skybrian.com/flux3-image-test/
htx619 · · focus · HN ↗
[dead]
swiftcoder · · focus · HN ↗
imgbenchdude · · focus · HN ↗
[dead]
k12sosse · · focus · HN ↗
Doohickey-d · · focus · HN ↗
cyanmagenta · · focus · HN ↗
mkl · · focus · HN ↗
hmstx · · focus · HN ↗
What else?
- Bunch of visible shape inconsistencies: building window sizes and alignment, fence railing, rivets on the bench, coins, accordion features, perspective violations etc...
- Metal clips on the bottom and top edges of the carrying case are on different sides. Said clips look inconsistent.
- One of the case straps originates inside (from under the velvet, even), the further one originates outside. The carrying handle is oddly mis-centered (as with most things).
- I'm not sure that accordion, compressed, fits in that case. She can just about stand in it (diagonally, on one foot).
- It has weird folds that disappear partway through and turn into adjacent folds going the other way. Between this, the keyboards and the dots, I'm sure there are other things wrong with accordion anatomy.
- Awkward left hand: not sure what's going on with the metacarpal joints, and index finger appears to begin forking into two tips pressing into two (misshapen) buttons. Her right hand is getting there too.
- Weird hair midline. I haven't seen a "sub-midline" like this in the wild :)
- The burgundy coat clips through the bench under her right leg. It's like the front slat goes through a hole in the side of the coat.
- We don't usually have that side curling bar on each side of the sitting area. It looks like it's clipping through the flats next to the leather handbag
- Ill-placed buckle on that bag.
- The green metal fence on the right begins behind her for one vertical bar, next one disappears into the plants, no further vertical bars, no top horizontal railing. Actually, it appears to only have fencing on one side, that's not something I'd see often. On the side where it does have a top, its top rail has very irregular width.
- Sand looks like... breadcrumbs? Very repetitive coarse shapes, like it was poorly done with a clone stamp.
- Something weird about the leaves.
- The foremost lamp isn't sure whether it has flat sides or not.
- The other lamp emerges out of nowhere from behind one of the blob-people in the alley.
- A bunch of unfortunate tangents and occlusions which make you wonder whether the diffusion hallucinated detail out of bigger shapes, or if it's been trained on photos where the tangents were done on purpose.
ie. center bottom bar of the bench being exactly aligned with the gray edge tiles, side curly railing-not-present-on-our-real-benches fully formed on her right, almost completely foreshortened out of existence where the bench's perspective forbids it...
Most people are fooled by much cruder fakes though. This is a lot better but keeps plenty of tells for observant people (and most people aren't)
motoxpro · · focus · HN ↗
Or just put in more than 10 words of effort, e.g. a better prompt and bounding boxed prompt edits, and all that stuff would be fixed now.
skybrian · · focus · HN ↗
When I was a kid, there was a game in the funny pages that asked you to find six things wrong in a picture. Someone should run a contest like that for AI-generated images.
It might be an interesting benchmark for vision models, too.