I feel like there has been a few takes on this (atuin desktop comes to mind[0] but apparently it's not a going concern anymore?) why hasn't it caught on?
I'm curious about this too. Org-babel, Jupyter, Atuin Desktop, etc. have explored similar ideas, but none became a mainstream way of working.
For people who used these tools long-term: what held them back? UX/accessibility, or do people simply prefer keeping documents separate from the actual work?
we saw a bunch of issues with desktop, in no particular order
1. authoring runbooks is difficult, most people barely document their work let alone make it executable
2. keeping runbooks up to date is difficult, they are error-prone across systems
3. agents are now pretty good at a number of the tasks these ideas solve for, and are good at working around issues caused by docs becoming out of date/etc
all these tools are great for your own notes, but are very difficult to scale
Ellie, I’ve greatly appreciated your work and your talks! Thanks for sharing your insights.
To give a bit more discouraging advice to Ledge, these tldr insights have made me run circles to resolve. My experience is that one will start getting into build system and dependency mapping to make this sustainable. And then if one wants something more universal, one ends up building something like homebrew, which doesn’t even cover all OSs for good reason.
As you dig deep across system dependency and updates and configurations, there are crazy, crazy, crazy cascading bugs that popup from personal experience. As an example of how this comes up in practice, this is why many teams end up building on Electron as a common cross-platform bug fixer (Tauri has catching up to do although generally works well).
edude03 · · focus · HN ↗
0: <a href="https://github.com/atuinsh/desktop" rel="nofollow">https://github.com/atuinsh/desktop
junehwi · · focus · HN ↗
For people who used these tools long-term: what held them back? UX/accessibility, or do people simply prefer keeping documents separate from the actual work?
ellieh · · focus · HN ↗
we saw a bunch of issues with desktop, in no particular order
1. authoring runbooks is difficult, most people barely document their work let alone make it executable
2. keeping runbooks up to date is difficult, they are error-prone across systems
3. agents are now pretty good at a number of the tasks these ideas solve for, and are good at working around issues caused by docs becoming out of date/etc
all these tools are great for your own notes, but are very difficult to scale
rancar2 · · focus · HN ↗
To give a bit more discouraging advice to Ledge, these tldr insights have made me run circles to resolve. My experience is that one will start getting into build system and dependency mapping to make this sustainable. And then if one wants something more universal, one ends up building something like homebrew, which doesn’t even cover all OSs for good reason.
As you dig deep across system dependency and updates and configurations, there are crazy, crazy, crazy cascading bugs that popup from personal experience. As an example of how this comes up in practice, this is why many teams end up building on Electron as a common cross-platform bug fixer (Tauri has catching up to do although generally works well).