Not so long ago I read something on HN which resonated with me: we’re moving into the era that is comparable to car mechanics enthusiasts. You have a previous generation of cars where people just enjoy working on with hand tools, and there’s modern cars where people like to tune with software patches.
From the very start of llms I’ve had nothing but bad experiences with code that was generated for me. Either it’s buggy, it works but I end up losing an evening on some obscure bug, or it’s full of red flags.
My latest hobby project is just in a text editor with markup and that’s it. I’m also done with the augmented assistance in the IDE. I google things I forgot. I constantly read these amazing stories of people vibe-coding some firmware/driver that just works, and honestly I’m starting to question whether I’m reading the posts of some promotional bot.
> You have a previous generation of cars where people just enjoy working on with hand tools, and there’s modern cars where people like to tune with software patches.
I think this is a prettier picture than reality suggests, it's overly simplified and a statement people like because it's a variant of "everything is the same"
I think the analogy with cars is apt, but we should also like at what happened with cars. People are being locked out of fixing them, even for simple jobs that would usually be task that introduces someone to the hobby or career. Fixes like changing your oil or brakes. Remember that the Ford CEO said that cars are "too dangerous" to fix. Probably connected with the other thing they talk about... a $100 bn repair industry that they want a bigger piece of. There's an easy way to do that, John Deer and Apple have clearly shown that it's not hard, even when we get the right to repair. Is it any wonder far fewer people work on their cars these days? Ask the people with electric vehicles... there are people out there, just as there always will be, not the numbers do matter
Weirdly, I think LLMs would be much more useful if everything was open source. No need to hack your microwave to give it a firmware update to the door doesn't lock, just patch. More training for the LLMs and turns what would be a specialized task into one anyone can do if they point the LLM at the code. Plus, people submit patches to the source code, getting companies free work. There is a way everyone can win in this. Sometimes (often) being greedy prevents you from getting a bigger fill
chicken-stew · · focus · HN ↗
From the very start of llms I’ve had nothing but bad experiences with code that was generated for me. Either it’s buggy, it works but I end up losing an evening on some obscure bug, or it’s full of red flags.
My latest hobby project is just in a text editor with markup and that’s it. I’m also done with the augmented assistance in the IDE. I google things I forgot. I constantly read these amazing stories of people vibe-coding some firmware/driver that just works, and honestly I’m starting to question whether I’m reading the posts of some promotional bot.
godelski · · focus · HN ↗
I think the analogy with cars is apt, but we should also like at what happened with cars. People are being locked out of fixing them, even for simple jobs that would usually be task that introduces someone to the hobby or career. Fixes like changing your oil or brakes. Remember that the Ford CEO said that cars are "too dangerous" to fix. Probably connected with the other thing they talk about... a $100 bn repair industry that they want a bigger piece of. There's an easy way to do that, John Deer and Apple have clearly shown that it's not hard, even when we get the right to repair. Is it any wonder far fewer people work on their cars these days? Ask the people with electric vehicles... there are people out there, just as there always will be, not the numbers do matter
Weirdly, I think LLMs would be much more useful if everything was open source. No need to hack your microwave to give it a firmware update to the door doesn't lock, just patch. More training for the LLMs and turns what would be a specialized task into one anyone can do if they point the LLM at the code. Plus, people submit patches to the source code, getting companies free work. There is a way everyone can win in this. Sometimes (often) being greedy prevents you from getting a bigger fill