Thread

1. delichon · 1790389911 · focus · HN ↗

   > Regardless, the true takeaway of Isaacs’ experience is that ALPR technology, whether it’s from Flock or any of the other competitors in this space providing the same functionality (Axon, etc), is dangerous not only because it is so easily abused by police (or even by hackers) to invade the privacy and liberty of citizens, but also because it enables a lazy police department to outsource basic critical thinking to machines and then take action based on a single data point to ruin a person’s life.

   The accusation that some machine made any decision here goes beyond the reporting in the article. It seems concocted to raise AI alarm. All we have is that it supplied accurate data that police then abused. That isn't in the vicinity of "outsource[d] basic critical thinking to machines".

   I want such general government surveillance banned, but the machines in this story had no more volition than a breathalyzer.

   1. preg_match · 1790394184 · focus · HN ↗

      The machines matter, because we know how human behavior works. We know that if you give humans an automated tool that works most of the time, they get lazy, to the point where they make more mistakes than if they had no automation at all.

      1. wredcoll · 1790397829 · focus · HN ↗

         This should be emphasized more. Regardless of how technology could be used, we (should be) are responsible for how it is likely to be used.

         Guns can be used for all sorts of things. A handgun in a house is likely to be used for murder/suicide.

         1. Exoristos · 1790406141 · focus · HN ↗

            "A handgun in a house" is statistically extremely unlikely to be "used for murder/suicide."

            1. wredcoll · 1790438551 · focus · HN ↗

               It increases the incidences of both of those things happening compared to no gun.

               The total number is relatively small, but so are deaths from measles. Should we not decrease them where we can?

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.