‹ BackHN Continuity

Thread

PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock

507 points · 295 comments · Qision

  1. hobo123 · · focus · HN ↗
    Is this really a thing people want? I use Pipepipe, but auto skipping content is the one thing I turned off pretty fast. It can be pretty annoying (I think it was on the latest Tony Iommi video where it wanted to skip large portions).

    I don't mind the channels I like having sponsors, and if I do I just double tap forward a couple of times to skip the minute.

    1. franga2000 · · focus · HN ↗
      I love sponsorblock, it feels like adblock felt the first time I installed it.

      Every time I see a creator I like do a "smooth transition" from content to ad, it makes me feel betrayed. Not only are they about to read words someone else wrote for them and which they don't really believe, they spent an extra 15 seconds pretending it was part of the video in order to keep my full attention when they throw the sponsor name in my face. It's scummy behaviour.

      Creators need sponsors to pay the bills, just as they do ads, I get it. I don't fault them for the industry basically forcing them into these kinds of "integrated ad reads", as well as the fact basically all the sponsors have huge ethical problems. But I will not subject myself or the people who watch videos with me or on my devices to this brain rot.

      That's why I try to support them in other ways (YouTube Premium, Patreon, etc.) and run adblock and sponsorblock on everything. By my napkin math, they make more this way anyways.

      1. IshKebab · · focus · HN ↗
        And does it even work? I feel like the only person on YouTube who has a clue about sponsorship is LTT. Their spots are like 10 seconds which is short enough that sometimes I'll be too lazy to skip it. In contrast to those 2 minute segments where I 100% skip every time.

        Unless the goal of the spot is literally just "Our name exists!!" which tbf it probably is for all those VPN ads, it doesn't really make a whole lot of sense.

        Surely nobody watches the full ad segments?

        1. atollk · · focus · HN ↗
          It literally is "our name exists". It sticks in your subconscious and can influence you in the future.

          A great example of this is Raid Shadow Legends. They were sponsoring what felt like every channel, to the point where it became a meme. But at some point, someone is going to go through the app store looking for an app to help with their boredom and is going to see Raid, at which point their subconscious says "I know that name. I should check it out."

          1. IshKebab · · focus · HN ↗
            Then why bother with such long segments? Why not do what LTT does?
Open on Hacker News to reply ↗

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.