‹ BackHN Continuity

Thread

Why Omarchy Exists

31 points · 73 comments · mikae1

  1. kennywinker · · focus · HN ↗
    After using omarchy for almost a year, and every time I mentioned it people dogpiling about how it's just a bunch of config files not an OS - I tested that idea. Turns out they're pretty much right. Fedora + hyprland + a little messing around with config files to get the shortcuts I'd become familiar with back = about 95% of omarchy. Glad to be rid of any link to DHH, and happy to have a deeper understanding of what comprises my desktop environment. 10/10 would recommend.
    1. jr3592 · · focus · HN ↗
      whats your gripe with DHH? Honest question.
      1. bryanlarsen · · focus · HN ↗
        I&#x27;ll let you judge for yourself. This is just one post of his among many similar. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;world.hey.com&#x2F;dhh&#x2F;wolves-sheep-and-gypsies-ba44af6a" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;world.hey.com&#x2F;dhh&#x2F;wolves-sheep-and-gypsies-ba44af6a
        1. happytoexplain · · focus · HN ↗
          This doesn&#x27;t seem like a crazy take. The situation is horrible all around, and the reaction to the situation is hard to demonize from a humanistic point of view. This isn&#x27;t the wealthy complaining about the homeless sleeping on benches. It&#x27;s a dramatic crisis perpetuated by people who are not, largely, mentally ill in the sense that some homeless people are.
          1. kennywinker · · focus · HN ↗
            Starting off with an analogy about shooting wolves frames things in a decidedly violent way that makes me uncomfortable. I would not, ever, compare a group of humans with a group of animals that i am advocating for culling. I know enough history to know who does that.

            &gt; The vagrants are literally shitting in the bushes

            This is a simple failure of civics. If you have people somewhere, you provide them toilets or you get shit on the ground. Cities do it when festivals and street parties happen - but they don&#x27;t do it when homeless poeple show up, and then they spin it as disgusting behaviour on the part of the people. Everybody shits. If you had no access to a toilet, or place to dispose of your shit, you would shit on the street or in the bushes too. Fixating on shit is also an attempt to rile up your disgust reaction, and link it to a group of people.

            &gt; Partly because it didn&#x27;t tolerate vagrants and homeless people taking over public spaces (as has happened in so many American cities)

            A leading lie. American cities have problems with public homelessness because they have no social safety net, and an economy that drives up homelessness. Crackdowns, like my city has done, only spreads the problem out and makes providing services like toilets impossible. It wasn&#x27;t as bad before not because it &quot;wasn&#x27;t tolerated&quot; but because the economic conditions were less harsh in the postwar era.

            &gt; You have to act. You have to protect the sheep. Standing idly by while your livestock is devoured by predators or your neighborhood is taken over by migrants is a pathetic abdication of any functioning society&#x27;s most basic duty to its citizens.

            This is a straight up fascist mentality. Us vs them. Protect our weak from their strong. It leads VERY dark places. Ask yourself this - why are the wolves the migrants? Could you not just as easily frame them as the sheep in need of protecting? Have they not been abandoned and pushed out by society? Without a barn to sleep in, the sheep will wander where they aren&#x27;t welcome - is that the sheep&#x27;s fault, or the shepherd&#x27;s?

            1. jr3592 · · focus · HN ↗
              &gt; If you have people somewhere, you provide them toilets or you get shit on the ground.

              I have no idea if you&#x27;ve traveled much, but this has not been my experience traveling throughout major cities in Europe.

              There&#x27;s often NOT public bathrooms ANYWHERE yet streets are much cleaner than somewhere like San Francisco, where there actually are some public bathrooms.

              1. [deleted] · · focus · HN ↗

                [deleted]

Open on Hacker News to reply ↗

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.