‹ BackHN Continuity

Thread

George Lucas Returns to Earth, Bearing Gifts

121 points · 71 comments · surprisetalk

  1. slg · · focus · HN ↗
    It truly is a one of a kind museum. You'll see some of the most famous art in the world from people like Norman Rockwell and Frida Kahlo on the same walls as a random strip from Doonesbury or The Far Side. You'll walk through a reproduction of the Sistine Chapel shortly before walking through a reproduction of the podrace from Phantom Menace. You'll go to the theater and see a 60+ year old experimental short film made without a camera by pressing moth wings into film and then a few minutes later they'll show an episode of Cowboy Bebop.

    It's such a bizarre and idiosyncratic collection that the museum itself inspires as much thought as the art in it.

    1. grehbies · · focus · HN ↗
      Spoiler warning.

      EDIT: Get it? For the Museum of Narrative Art?

      In all seriousness, I think I would have preferred the [Renaissance masterpiece] -> [Pop culture artifact] progression to have been a surprise. People seem to be more and more focused on expressing their own exuberance and less on preserving for everyone else the experience they put so much stock into. It's a bit selfish and hypocritical.

      I knew who Luke's father was years before I saw Empire, and I can only imagine what a shock that must have been to people who didn't. I can only imagine. It would have been nice to have known, though.

      1. slg · · focus · HN ↗
        > I think I would have preferred the [Renaissance masterpiece] -> [Pop culture artifact] progression to have been a surprise.

        I never imagined I would be accused of posting spoilers for a museum, but even if we accept the idea that a museum can have spoilers, I think you're reading too much into what I said. There's no overt progression in the curation. I was simply detailing what I was thinking as I browsed the museum. In fact, the museum seems to be specifically designed to let the visitors experience the museum however they want. It was just my personal experience that this attempt to background the curation paradoxically had me thinking more about that curation than if they took a more traditional approach.

        1. grehbies · · focus · HN ↗
          >In fact, the museum seems to be specifically designed to let the visitors experience the museum however they want.

          You don't think that telling people what's there might get in the way of an unadulterated experience? Some people want to go in blind.

Open on Hacker News to reply ↗

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.