‹ BackHN Continuity

Thread

Bill to Ban Private Equity from Owning Medical Practices

509 points · 384 comments · paimapi

  1. NegativeK · · focus · HN ↗
    Can someone steelman private equity, please? I'm honestly looking for the upsides (for non-investors) of when PE moves into an industry like medicine and begins buying up businesses that traditionally aren't already large chains.

    I already hear the downsides frequently from someone whose work is directly affected.

    1. tbrownaw · · focus · HN ↗
      > Can someone steelman private equity, please?

      Step back and look at what it fundamentally is.

      Person A has a business they want to sell.

      Person B has a pile of money and thinks that that business is (or can be) a good investment.

      That's it.

      So, what happens if person A is prohibited from selling their business? Are they forced to keep working because they don't have enough other savings to retire on? Do they shut the business down in order to retire? Something else?

      .

      Calls to ban private equity are attempts to play "shoot the messenger".

      1. Xirdus · · focus · HN ↗
        > So, what happens if person A is prohibited from selling their business?

        I actually made that thought experiment. Disallow selling businesses. Disallow selling shares. Disallow stock market. Disallow mergers. The only way to acquire a business is to found it or to inherit it. The only way to quit a business is to shut it all down, with all assets liquidated, all liabilities settled, and all contracts terminated.

        The main downside is that it's harder for to make money. Otherwise... I only see positives. And no, it wouldn't kill innovation. The investors would just have to invest the old fashioned way - by founding companies or expanding their existing businesses. As for job security, we already don't have it in the current system.

        1. tacostakohashi · · focus · HN ↗
          Private property is theft!

          Disallow eyeglasses. Abolish money.

          Any other good ideas?

          1. NegativeK · · focus · HN ↗
            I don't agree with the parent of your comment, but saying they're a Maoist is way too far from my request of steelmanning.
Open on Hacker News to reply ↗

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.