‹ BackHN Continuity

Thread

Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?

293 points · 384 comments · auggierose

  1. strideashort · · focus · HN ↗
    We need to pivot math towards intuition and accessibility.

    Math has built a gated, inaccessible institution which - by design or not - served as a moat.

    I believe math has little to do with mathematical notation - intuition is much more important. One can have intuition but not be able to “read math” - much as many musicians don’t “read music”.

    Reading math however does not guarantee ideas or intuition. And those are what math needs.

    1. bluecheese452 · · focus · HN ↗
      These “intuition” people are the biggest gatekeepers of all. Forget studying and working hard, unless you have intuition you don’t count.
      1. hiddencost · · focus · HN ↗
        Sounds like someone was cruel to you at one point. The parent likely means the opposite of what you're suggesting.

        Most people consider mathematical intuition something that only develops from deep study. What the parent is referring to is being able to anticipate how a system will behave before you actually do the calculation.

        Most people who use mathematics in an industry job rely on their intuition rather than rigorous proofs. And most industry mathematicians will acknowledge that they're not as rigorous, nor as academically gifted, as their friends who stayed in academia.

        Just like a programmer with 20 years of experience can look at a bug and anticipate the cause.

Open on Hacker News to reply ↗

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.