Passkeys do marginally improve security against MITM and phishing attacks, but they are primarily for protecting the lowest common denominator from themselves: people who re-use passwords and/or don't use a password manager.
If you use multiple devices throughout the day, registering passkeys in all of these systems becomes a big headache with O(m*n) complexity, so putting the passkeys in a password manager is the only realistic solution. But this still breaks the login flow for a very common use case: how do I log in on a device that I don't own? With a password in a password manager I at least have the option of manually typing the password.
The biggest problem, though, is how users are pushed into it without any warning or knowledge of what they're signing up for. I've accidentally set up passkeys just by clicking an okay button a few times in the past and had to go back and figure out how to undo it after being blocked from login on another computer (which computer was I on again?).
> how do I log in on a device that I don't own?
This is solved by passkey-implementing software and devices (with Bluetooth) allowing you to log in with a QR code (Webauthn via CTAP hybrid transport). iOS and Android support this, and it’s generally not a locked-down thing if other devices wanted to do it too.
The only use case left is in “how do I login if all my devices are stolen/fall into a body of water” in which there really isn’t an answer beyond “get (a|your) device back, sign back into your password manager, use that to get back into critical accounts”.
They're cheap enough if you lose one it's not the end of the world. Goes on your keyring. Doesn't require esim management. Use NFC swipe/usb-plug-in + pin to use.
The problem isn't the cost of replacing it, the problem is - how do you log in when all your passkey-bearing devices just got flushed down the toilet?
How is that different from accidentally deleting your keepass database? Or forgetting your password? I think it’d be easier for me to forget than find myself trying to flush all my hw tokens…
Same way. A majority generally have a old phone that was already signed in to google. Or if they remember only Apple ID and password (one very difficult password) + sms. They can login on to a new phone.
Everything is SYNCED immediately.
What if you have a ransomeware that destroy everything on the same day your house and all backups burn down. And you cant get it from immutable backups as you wrote that decryption key in paper. And the bank will not allow you to access it as the govt deported you elsewhere.
I can back up my FIDO2 (non-)resident keys too. In the end it's just a piece of HW with some secret material inside. non-resident FIDO2 keys are easier to back up, because the master secret seed is fixed and shared for all origins and there's nothing stored on the key.
I can get another hw key (if one of mine breaks, which I, surprisingly enough, have not yet managed to achieve)
And since I have at least two at all times, the possibility of one of them breaking changes… not much really.
Paper can burn or get tossed, backups files can go corrupt, and I really don't understand what is that extra risk hw keys introduce…
There is at least one valid (in my opinion) reason to not like hw keys though: they cost real money to acquire, so you probably want an extra margin in your budget for the unlikely case they indeed decide to break.
> Also... Is flushing your whole keys down the toilet a problem you run into often?
It's a potential catastrophe I'd like to avoid if possible, but the catastrophe is not inherent to any other key I have.
House key: Make new copy for 10 USD. Alternatively, get a locksmith to unlock the door and change the lock. Even more alternatively, break a window or door. I still get into my house.
Car key: Make a new copy for >10 USD. Alternatively, call roadside assistance and get them to tow me somewhere I can get a new key. More inconvenient, still very possible.
TOTP 2FA and passwords: Password databases can be backed up, and so can TOTP seeds. It's inconvenient to do so, but I can at least still just leave copies around everywhere I can, so that it's extremely unlikely that I'll be completely locked out.
Yubikey: Making copies is literally impossible, so I'll need to buy two or three keys from the get go, and get them all out every time I need to add a new key. This is a huge inconvenience that no casual user will ever do (they might do 3-2-1 if it was set-and-forget, but Yubikeys aren't). If I don't do this, I lose permanent access to my accounts. There is no safety valve built in to the system. If I lose my key, I'm fucked.
But a majority don't do that. For them let them use passkeys. If the possibility is once in 10 years then I am happy to do that. A majority is happy to do that.
And yes, Google or Apple - dont say you should not keep passwords in your database and sync it with dropbox. DIY.
Copy pasting my other comment from an earlier thread
FIDO2 USB Security key -> Bitwarden (With master password) -> Every other method (topt/password)
I have 3 FIDO2 USB Security keys, One I carry with my persons at all times, one that stays with my main machine at all times and an offsite backup that is sitting in a friend's server, if my house burns down, I can either physically collect the key or use USB-IP to authenticate back into bitwarden and enroll a new key. (Actually all 3 are at home right now but that's ok)
what do you do when you forget your password? and what is the relative frequency of the average user forgetting a password vs flushing their authenticator device down the toilet?
I recommend a reciprocating saw with a metal cutting blade to get them into small enough pieces. Do not try to flush them all of the pieces at the same time. It's not just about whether they fit or not, they also need to be light enough for the water current of the flush to carry them all the way through. Otherwise, they may end up in the water trap and hinder your future use of the appliance. For small partial blockages, it may be possible to consume some extra fiber in order to be able to "sweep" some of the metallic remnants along, but this will void both your warranty and your bowels.
I am a doctor -- and a lawyer and an orbital mechanics specialist, as well as a highly respected behavioral therapist -- so you can trust my advice. Also, feel free to consult an AI on this topic; it would make for an amusing benchmark.
drtz · · focus · HN ↗
If you use multiple devices throughout the day, registering passkeys in all of these systems becomes a big headache with O(m*n) complexity, so putting the passkeys in a password manager is the only realistic solution. But this still breaks the login flow for a very common use case: how do I log in on a device that I don't own? With a password in a password manager I at least have the option of manually typing the password.
The biggest problem, though, is how users are pushed into it without any warning or knowledge of what they're signing up for. I've accidentally set up passkeys just by clicking an okay button a few times in the past and had to go back and figure out how to undo it after being blocked from login on another computer (which computer was I on again?).
judge2020 · · focus · HN ↗
This is solved by passkey-implementing software and devices (with Bluetooth) allowing you to log in with a QR code (Webauthn via CTAP hybrid transport). iOS and Android support this, and it’s generally not a locked-down thing if other devices wanted to do it too.
The only use case left is in “how do I login if all my devices are stolen/fall into a body of water” in which there really isn’t an answer beyond “get (a|your) device back, sign back into your password manager, use that to get back into critical accounts”.
esseph · · focus · HN ↗
They're cheap enough if you lose one it's not the end of the world. Goes on your keyring. Doesn't require esim management. Use NFC swipe/usb-plug-in + pin to use.
pavel_lishin · · focus · HN ↗
remix2000 · · focus · HN ↗
pavel_lishin · · focus · HN ↗
faust201 · · focus · HN ↗
Everything is SYNCED immediately.
What if you have a ransomeware that destroy everything on the same day your house and all backups burn down. And you cant get it from immutable backups as you wrote that decryption key in paper. And the bank will not allow you to access it as the govt deported you elsewhere.
megous · · focus · HN ↗
remix2000 · · focus · HN ↗
And since I have at least two at all times, the possibility of one of them breaking changes… not much really.
Paper can burn or get tossed, backups files can go corrupt, and I really don't understand what is that extra risk hw keys introduce…
There is at least one valid (in my opinion) reason to not like hw keys though: they cost real money to acquire, so you probably want an extra margin in your budget for the unlikely case they indeed decide to break.
esseph · · focus · HN ↗
Telaneo · · focus · HN ↗
It's a potential catastrophe I'd like to avoid if possible, but the catastrophe is not inherent to any other key I have.
House key: Make new copy for 10 USD. Alternatively, get a locksmith to unlock the door and change the lock. Even more alternatively, break a window or door. I still get into my house.
Car key: Make a new copy for >10 USD. Alternatively, call roadside assistance and get them to tow me somewhere I can get a new key. More inconvenient, still very possible.
TOTP 2FA and passwords: Password databases can be backed up, and so can TOTP seeds. It's inconvenient to do so, but I can at least still just leave copies around everywhere I can, so that it's extremely unlikely that I'll be completely locked out.
Yubikey: Making copies is literally impossible, so I'll need to buy two or three keys from the get go, and get them all out every time I need to add a new key. This is a huge inconvenience that no casual user will ever do (they might do 3-2-1 if it was set-and-forget, but Yubikeys aren't). If I don't do this, I lose permanent access to my accounts. There is no safety valve built in to the system. If I lose my key, I'm fucked.
faust201 · · focus · HN ↗
And yes, Google or Apple - dont say you should not keep passwords in your database and sync it with dropbox. DIY.
Rest of us want convenience.
vablings · · focus · HN ↗
FIDO2 USB Security key -> Bitwarden (With master password) -> Every other method (topt/password)
I have 3 FIDO2 USB Security keys, One I carry with my persons at all times, one that stays with my main machine at all times and an offsite backup that is sitting in a friend's server, if my house burns down, I can either physically collect the key or use USB-IP to authenticate back into bitwarden and enroll a new key. (Actually all 3 are at home right now but that's ok)
notatoad · · focus · HN ↗
vel0city · · focus · HN ↗
sfink · · focus · HN ↗
I am a doctor -- and a lawyer and an orbital mechanics specialist, as well as a highly respected behavioral therapist -- so you can trust my advice. Also, feel free to consult an AI on this topic; it would make for an amusing benchmark.
pavel_lishin · · focus · HN ↗
ndriscoll · · focus · HN ↗
esseph · · focus · HN ↗