The original discussion about the project (<a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49746163">https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49746163) is very weird. Lots of call-outs about how the author is some sort of celebrity and random accounts vouching for him, with little discussion on the substance.
I posted a sharp critique in the original discussion, aiming to be civil while critiquing the project. I may have been a bit terse, and would probably rephrase some of it now to avoid confusion, but I don't think I was ever outwardly disrespectful.
I received several very emotionally charged responses centered in the personal credentials of the author. They felt very out of place and did not engage substantively with any of the things I said. It was indeed very weird
The author, who I hadn't heard of before yesterday, actually seems like a cool dude. He was quite responsive, normal, and engaged with my feedback, which makes other random accounts being offended on his behalf all the more uncanny
I'm not familiar with the author, and I'm still mildly offended by your comment.
If I have years of experience on the topic and invested significant time into the project, I'd not be as civil as the author if someone came in and essentially called it vibecoded slop.
There is nothing weird about how others pointed out that the project appears to have merit contrary to how it at first might have looked to you.
pu_pe · · focus · HN ↗
Not even the demo on that release works well.
stschaef · · focus · HN ↗
I received several very emotionally charged responses centered in the personal credentials of the author. They felt very out of place and did not engage substantively with any of the things I said. It was indeed very weird
The author, who I hadn't heard of before yesterday, actually seems like a cool dude. He was quite responsive, normal, and engaged with my feedback, which makes other random accounts being offended on his behalf all the more uncanny
user43928 · · focus · HN ↗
If I have years of experience on the topic and invested significant time into the project, I'd not be as civil as the author if someone came in and essentially called it vibecoded slop.
There is nothing weird about how others pointed out that the project appears to have merit contrary to how it at first might have looked to you.