Thread

1. CSMastermind · 1789709616 · focus · HN ↗

   Apples have some of wildest biology that I've seen as a non-professional biologist. At many genes, they carry two different alleles instead of two matching ones. They're almost all self-incompatible. A Honeycrisp flower cannot pollinate a Honeycrisp flower.

   This means that you can't breed them in the traditional sense that we do with other plants. Outside of Granny Smith apples the ones you eat are mostly the results of mutations in the grown plants that we cut off and graft.

   1. jmartrican · 1789755641 · focus · HN ↗

      Oh wow you may have just answered a question I been having. I planted some apple trees in my backyard. The AI helping me suggested 3 trees, one of which was a crab-apple tree that it said will be used to pollinate the other two. Maybe it lied to me. But i did follow its instructions. I was wondering why the other two (Honeycrisp and another delicious variety) could not just pollinate each other.

      1. pvaldes · 1789847122 · focus · HN ↗

         Professional advice is the way to go. Much better than AI. Two trees of exactly the same apple cultivar will perform wildly different depending on were you buy it.

         Crab-apples are good for pollination IF they overlap flowering. Not so much otherwise. If you have an early flowering variety and a late flowering crab-apple forget it. You don't need them as a third apple may work perfectly.

         In any case they are beautiful trees and excellent for wildlife. You will not be disappointed with the excellent spring and fall displays, but if the space is limited I would go for a different tree or a third real apple choosing carefully the rootstock. If you want a crab-apple put it at the background. (Optical effect. It makes the garden appear bigger). If you like to watch birds while sipping your coffee in the front.

         Crab-apples would be the kings of garden if they didn't suffered from so many diseases.

Unofficial Hacker News client; not affiliated with Y Combinator.